PEBBLEWIRE /

Medicare Open Enrollment: What to Compare Before December 7

Medicare's December 7 deadline is approaching. We examine real UnitedHealthcare and Humana plans, explain 2027 premiums and prescription drug costs, and show what to check before changing coverage.

Medicare Advantage premiums are expected to decline in 2027, but lower premiums don’t necessarily mean lower healthcare costs. Here’s what to compare before the enrollment deadline.

If you’re enrolled in Medicare, December 7 is one of the most important dates on your financial calendar.

It’s the final day of Medicare’s annual Open Enrollment Period, when eligible beneficiaries can review their coverage and switch plans for the coming year.

And there’s plenty to consider for 2027.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) projects that average Medicare Advantage plan premiums will decline by more than 16%.

Meanwhile, the average monthly premium for standalone Medicare Part D prescription drug coverage is expected to increase slightly.

But those national averages don’t necessarily reflect what you’ll pay.

Your costs depend on your specific plan, prescriptions, doctors, and location.

The cheapest Medicare plan isn’t necessarily the one with the lowest monthly premium. It’s the one that provides appropriate coverage at a manageable total cost.

Here’s what to check before December 7.

1. What’s Changing With Medicare in 2027?

CMS released its Medicare Advantage and Part D projections in September.

The agency expects average premiums for Medicare Advantage plans to decline in 2027.

Standalone prescription drug coverage is projected to become slightly more expensive on average.

2027 Medicare Premium Outlook

Coverage2026 Average2027 Projection
Medicare Advantage$14.37/month$12.00/month
Standalone Part D$35.09/month$36.00/month

Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, September 2026 Medicare Advantage and Part D premium projections.

These are projected national averages, not guaranteed prices for individual beneficiaries.

The figures also don’t include every expense associated with Medicare.

For example, most people enrolled in Medicare Advantage must continue paying their Medicare Part B premium.

And plan premiums don’t include deductibles, copayments, or other medical expenses.

That’s why comparing total annual costs matters more than focusing on the monthly premium alone.

2. Original Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage

Before comparing insurance companies, it’s important to understand the two main ways to receive Medicare health coverage.

Original Medicare

Original Medicare includes:

Part A: Hospital insurance.

Part B: Medical insurance covering services such as doctor visits, outpatient care, and certain medical equipment.

Original Medicare generally allows you to visit doctors and hospitals throughout the United States that accept Medicare.

You don’t usually need referrals to see specialists.

However, Original Medicare doesn’t include comprehensive outpatient prescription drug coverage.

You can generally purchase a separate Part D plan.

You may also be able to purchase Medicare Supplement Insurance, known as Medigap, to help cover certain out-of-pocket expenses.

Medicare Advantage

Medicare Advantage, also called Part C, is offered by Medicare-approved private insurers.

These plans provide an alternative way to receive Medicare Part A and Part B benefits.

Most also include Part D prescription drug coverage.

Some offer additional benefits such as dental, vision, or hearing services.

But Medicare Advantage plans frequently use provider networks and may require referrals or prior authorization for certain services.

Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureOriginal MedicareMedicare Advantage
AdministrationFederal Medicare programPrivate Medicare-approved insurer
Hospital coveragePart AIncluded
Medical coveragePart BIncluded
Prescription coverageSeparate Part D generally availableIncluded in most plans
Provider accessGenerally nationwide, where Medicare is acceptedOften subject to plan networks
Specialist referralsGenerally not requiredDepends on plan
Annual medical out-of-pocket maximumNone under Original Medicare aloneRequired for covered Part A and B services
Additional dental, vision, or hearing benefitsGenerally limitedMay be included
Medigap compatibilityCan supplement Original MedicareCannot be used with Medicare Advantage

Neither option is universally better.

Someone who values broad access to physicians may prefer Original Medicare.

Someone seeking integrated coverage with an annual medical out-of-pocket limit may find a Medicare Advantage plan appealing.

But the details of the actual coverage are essential.

3. Real-World Example: UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage

UnitedHealthcare is one of the largest Medicare Advantage insurers in the United States.

Its 2027 offerings include plans with different network structures, costs, and supplemental benefits.

For example, UnitedHealthcare offers the AARP Medicare Advantage from UHC CO-0001 (HMO-POS) plan in parts of Colorado.

This is an actual 2027 Medicare Advantage product.

The HMO-POS designation means it’s a Health Maintenance Organization plan with a point-of-service feature.

That structure generally emphasizes network providers while allowing certain out-of-network services under the plan’s rules.

But the important point is that UnitedHealthcare doesn’t offer one identical Medicare Advantage plan nationwide.

Its plans vary by county.

What to Check With UnitedHealthcare

Before selecting a UnitedHealthcare plan, review:

Monthly premium: How much does the specific plan charge?

Medical deductible: Does the plan impose a deductible for covered medical services?

Out-of-pocket maximum: What’s the annual limit for covered medical expenses?

Provider network: Are your doctors and hospitals included?

Prescription coverage: Are your medications covered, and at what cost?

Dental and vision benefits: What specific services and annual limits apply?

UnitedHealthcare’s national marketing materials may describe benefits offered across portions of its plan portfolio.

Those descriptions don’t guarantee that every local plan includes the same benefits.

For the most accurate comparison, use the exact plan name, contract number, and 2027 Summary of Benefits.

4. Real-World Example: Humana Gold Plus

Humana is another major Medicare Advantage insurer.

Its Humana Gold Plus HMO product family provides another real-world example of how Medicare Advantage coverage works.

Humana Gold Plus plans generally use an HMO structure.

That means members typically receive routine care from participating network providers and may need referrals for certain specialist services.

Specific requirements vary by plan.

Some Humana plans include prescription drug coverage and supplemental benefits.

However, the exact monthly premiums, copayments, drug formularies, and provider networks depend on the plan available in your location.

UnitedHealthcare vs. Humana: What Matters?

FeatureUnitedHealthcare Medicare AdvantageHumana Gold Plus HMO
InsurerUnitedHealthcareHumana
Product structureHMO, HMO-POS, PPO and other optionsHMO product family
Prescription coverageAvailable in qualifying plansAvailable in qualifying plans
Provider networksPlan-specificPlan-specific
Dental and visionMay be availableMay be available
Monthly premiumsVary by plan and locationVary by plan and location
Out-of-pocket limitsPlan-specificPlan-specific
EligibilityDepends on Medicare status and service areaDepends on Medicare status and service area

Both companies offer legitimate Medicare-approved products.

But their national product families cannot be compared as if they were two standardized insurance policies.

A meaningful price comparison requires two specific plans available to the same beneficiary.

For example, a retiree living in Denver should compare the actual UnitedHealthcare and Humana plans available in that ZIP code—not national averages or plans sold in another state.

The insurer’s name alone doesn’t establish which product offers better coverage.

5. Don’t Mistake a $0 Premium for Free Healthcare

Some Medicare Advantage plans advertise a $0 monthly plan premium.

That can sound attractive.

But a $0 plan premium doesn’t mean the enrollee has no healthcare costs.

Most Medicare Advantage beneficiaries must continue paying the Medicare Part B premium.

In 2026, the standard Part B premium is $202.90 per month.

The final standard premium for 2027 had not yet been announced at the time of this article.

CMS’s Medicare trustees previously projected a 2027 standard Part B premium of $209.50, but that figure is an estimate, not the final announced amount.

Other expenses may include:

  • Doctor visit copayments.
  • Specialist copayments.
  • Hospital cost-sharing.
  • Prescription drug expenses.
  • Out-of-network charges.
  • Costs for services not covered by the plan.

What Does a $0 Plan Premium Actually Mean?

It means the plan doesn’t charge an additional monthly premium under the quoted plan terms.

It doesn’t eliminate Medicare Part B obligations or the plan’s cost-sharing requirements.

That’s why consumers should compare their potential total annual expenses.

A plan charging $0 monthly could still cost more than a higher-premium alternative during a year involving substantial medical treatment.

6. Prescription Drug Coverage Is Changing in 2027

For people who take prescription medications regularly, Part D coverage may be one of the most important components of their Medicare decision.

A major protection continues in 2027.

The annual out-of-pocket threshold for covered Part D prescription drugs increases to $2,400.

This compares with $2,100 in 2026.

Once qualifying out-of-pocket spending reaches that threshold, enrollees generally pay no additional cost-sharing for covered Part D medications during the remainder of the calendar year.

However, the threshold doesn’t include monthly plan premiums or every possible medication expense.

Drugs that aren’t covered under Part D may still generate separate costs.

2027 Part D Cost Limits

Feature2027 Amount
Maximum permitted annual deductible$700
Annual out-of-pocket threshold$2,400
Cost-sharing after reaching thresholdGenerally $0 for covered Part D drugs

Some plans have lower deductibles or no deductible.

And different plans can charge very different amounts for the same medication before an enrollee reaches the threshold.

Real-World Example: Comparing Drug Coverage

Suppose someone takes three regular prescription medications.

One plan covers all three as preferred medications.

Another covers two as preferred drugs but places the third on a more expensive formulary tier.

Even if the second plan has a lower monthly premium, its total annual prescription costs could be higher.

That’s why Medicare’s Plan Finder allows users to enter their actual medications and compare estimated costs.

The most useful comparison is based on the specific drugs you take—not simply the insurer’s advertised premium.

7. Check Your Doctors Before Switching Plans

Provider networks can be a major difference between Medicare Advantage plans.

Imagine that you’ve visited the same cardiologist for several years.

Your current Medicare Advantage plan includes that physician.

But a competing plan with a lower premium doesn’t.

Switching could require you to find another specialist or pay more for certain out-of-network care, depending on the plan’s rules.

That makes provider access an important part of comparing insurance costs.

Before enrolling, confirm whether your preferred physicians, specialists, hospitals, and treatment facilities participate in the specific plan.

Don’t rely exclusively on an insurer’s general network description.

Contact the provider’s office and verify that it accepts the exact plan for the relevant coverage year.

Also check whether referrals or prior authorization are required for services you regularly use.

8. Look at the Annual Out-of-Pocket Maximum

Medicare Advantage plans have annual out-of-pocket limits for covered Part A and Part B services.

That provides a form of financial protection against high medical cost-sharing.

However, the maximum varies by plan.

It also doesn’t necessarily include every expense.

Monthly premiums, Part D prescription drug spending, and noncovered services generally don’t count toward the Medicare Advantage medical out-of-pocket limit.

Some plans also have different limits for in-network and combined in-network/out-of-network services.

Why This Matters

Consider two hypothetical Medicare Advantage plans.

FeaturePlan APlan B
Additional monthly plan premium$0$45
Annual plan premium$0$540
In-network medical out-of-pocket maximum$7,000$4,000

Plan A has no additional monthly premium.

Plan B costs $540 annually in premiums.

But Plan B has a lower annual medical out-of-pocket maximum.

For someone expecting significant treatment, that difference could matter.

This illustration excludes the Part B premium and prescription expenses and assumes the same covered services and applicable provider access.

Neither option can be declared cheaper without considering expected healthcare use.

The goal is to compare total financial exposure, not just monthly premiums.

9. What About Medigap?

Medicare Supplement Insurance, commonly known as Medigap, helps cover certain out-of-pocket expenses under Original Medicare.

For example, a Medigap policy may help pay some deductibles, copayments, or coinsurance.

But Medigap works with Original Medicare, not Medicare Advantage.

This is an important distinction for beneficiaries considering switching coverage.

The Medigap Warning

If you leave a Medicare Advantage plan and return to Original Medicare, you may want to purchase Medigap coverage.

However, the ability to buy a Medigap policy isn’t guaranteed in every circumstance.

Outside certain enrollment periods and guaranteed-issue situations, insurers may be permitted to evaluate your health history when determining eligibility or pricing, depending on applicable state and federal rules.

That means switching from Medicare Advantage back to Original Medicare can have consequences beyond the immediate plan change.

Before making the switch, verify whether you’re eligible to obtain the Medigap coverage you want.

Don’t assume that returning to Original Medicare automatically guarantees access to any Medigap policy.

10. Review Your Annual Notice of Change

If you’re already enrolled in Medicare Advantage or Part D, your plan should provide an Annual Notice of Change, commonly called an ANOC.

This document explains important changes to your coverage for the following year.

These changes can include:

  • Monthly premiums.
  • Deductibles.
  • Copayments and coinsurance.
  • Out-of-pocket limits.
  • Covered benefits.
  • Prescription drug coverage.

For 2027, review this document carefully.

A plan that worked well in 2026 may have different costs or coverage next year.

A medication could move to another formulary tier.

A provider network could change.

Or the plan could modify a supplemental benefit that you regularly use.

The Annual Notice of Change helps identify those differences before enrollment decisions become final.

11. Compare Plans Using Medicare Plan Finder

Medicare’s official Plan Finder is one of the most useful tools for evaluating coverage.

It allows beneficiaries to compare Medicare Advantage and Part D options available in their area.

To begin, visit Medicare.gov and select the plan comparison tool.

Enter your ZIP code and choose the type of coverage you want to compare.

You can also enter prescription medications and preferred pharmacies to estimate drug expenses.

What to Compare

FactorWhy It Matters
Monthly premiumDetermines recurring insurance cost
Medical deductibleAffects upfront medical expenses
Out-of-pocket maximumLimits certain covered medical costs
Doctors and hospitalsDetermines access to preferred providers
Prescription formularyDetermines medication coverage
Pharmacy networkCan affect prescription costs
Star RatingProvides CMS quality information
Supplemental benefitsMay provide additional services

CMS publishes quality ratings for Medicare Advantage and Part D plans.

These ratings can help consumers assess plan performance.

However, a higher Star Rating doesn’t automatically mean the plan has the lowest cost or includes your preferred physicians.

Use quality ratings alongside the plan’s actual benefits and coverage conditions.

12. When Is the Medicare Enrollment Deadline?

For 2027 coverage, Medicare’s annual Open Enrollment Period runs from October 15 through December 7, 2026.

Changes made during this period generally become effective January 1, 2027.

Important Medicare Dates

DateWhat Happens
October 15, 2026Medicare Open Enrollment begins
December 7, 2026Open Enrollment ends
January 1, 2027New coverage selections generally take effect
January 1–March 31, 2027Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period

The January–March period has different rules.

It generally allows people already enrolled in Medicare Advantage to make one qualifying change, including switching to another Medicare Advantage plan or returning to Original Medicare.

It isn’t a general opportunity for everyone to make any Medicare coverage change.

Special Enrollment Periods may also apply in certain circumstances.

To avoid unnecessary complications, complete your regular annual plan comparison before December 7.

13. Your Medicare Open Enrollment Checklist

Before selecting coverage for 2027, review these questions.

1. Has my monthly premium changed?

Compare the actual premium for your current plan with the 2027 amount.

2. Are my doctors still covered?

Confirm provider participation in the exact plan you’re considering.

3. Are my medications covered?

Check the 2027 formulary and pharmacy network.

4. What is my maximum financial exposure?

Review medical deductibles, copayments, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket limits.

5. Do I need supplemental coverage?

If considering Original Medicare, determine whether Medigap and standalone Part D coverage fit your needs.

6. Am I eligible for additional assistance?

Medicare Savings Programs and Extra Help may reduce costs for eligible people with limited income and resources.

7. Have I reviewed my Annual Notice of Change?

Understand how your existing plan will differ in 2027.

8. Have I checked my actual enrollment deadline?

Complete any intended annual changes by December 7, unless a different enrollment opportunity applies.

The PebbleWire Takeaway

Lower Medicare Advantage premiums in 2027 don’t guarantee that every beneficiary will spend less on healthcare.

CMS projects average Medicare Advantage premiums will decline to approximately $12 per month.

But your actual costs depend on your plan, doctors, medications, and medical needs.

Real products from UnitedHealthcare and Humana illustrate why comparing insurers by brand name alone isn’t enough.

The same insurer can offer multiple plans with different networks, premiums, and cost-sharing requirements.

Prescription drug coverage also deserves attention, especially with the 2027 Part D out-of-pocket threshold set at $2,400.

Before December 7, review your existing coverage, compare actual local plans, and calculate your potential annual costs.

The right Medicare plan isn’t simply the cheapest one. It’s the coverage that best balances affordability, access, and financial protection.


Sources

  1. Medicare.gov — Medicare Open Enrollment.
  2. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services — Medicare Advantage and Medicare Prescription Drug Programs Expected to Remain Stable in 2027, September 2026.
  3. Medicare.gov — Compare Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage.
  4. Medicare.gov — How Much Does Medicare Drug Coverage Cost?
  5. Medicare.gov — Medicare Plan Finder, 2027.
  6. UnitedHealthcare — 2027 Medicare Advantage Plans.
  7. UnitedHealthcare — AARP Medicare Advantage from UHC CO-0001, 2027 Plan Information.
  8. Humana — 2027 Medicare Advantage Plans.
  9. Humana — Humana Gold Plus HMO.
  10. Medicare.gov — When Can I Buy a Medigap Policy?
  11. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services — 2027 Medicare Advantage and Part D Star Ratings.

Product information reviewed: November 4, 2026.

Editorial note: The UnitedHealthcare and Humana products discussed are real Medicare Advantage offerings. The comparison describes product structures rather than assuming nationwide availability or identical benefits. Individual premiums, provider networks, and cost-sharing amounts must be verified by ZIP code and specific plan contract.

2027 Part B note: The standard 2027 Medicare Part B premium was not yet final at the time of this draft. The 2026 standard premium is $202.90; the trustees’ projected 2027 amount of $209.50 is not a confirmed final rate.

Disclaimer

PebbleWire provides financial news and educational content for informational purposes only. This article does not constitute personalized financial, medical, insurance, tax, or legal advice. Medicare eligibility, enrollment rights, premiums, provider networks, and benefits vary. Confirm current coverage details through Medicare.gov, the applicable insurer, or a qualified State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor before making enrollment decisions.

MORE TO EXPLORE

PEBBLEWIRE / FINANCIAL CLARITY FOR EVERY DAY