PEBBLEWIRE /

Medicare Part D Premiums Could Rise 50% in 2027: How to Compare Plans

Medicare Part D premiums could increase 50% for existing enrollees who don't switch plans in 2027, according to KFF. We compare real prescription drug plans and explain how to avoid paying more than necessary.

Keeping your current prescription drug plan could become considerably more expensive next year. But shopping around may help you avoid unnecessary costs.

If you have Medicare prescription drug coverage, renewing your current plan without checking alternatives could be an expensive decision.

A new analysis from health policy research organization KFF estimates that average monthly premiums for standalone Medicare Part D plans could increase 50% in 2027 for existing enrollees who remain in their current plans.

That would push the estimated average premium from $34 per month in 2026 to $51 in 2027.

For someone paying those amounts, the increase represents an additional $204 annually.

But here’s the important distinction.

Not every Medicare beneficiary will experience a 50% premium increase.

Some plans are becoming considerably more expensive, while others will see relatively modest changes or even premium reductions.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has separately projected an average standalone Part D premium of approximately $36 per month for 2027.

Those two projections measure different things and shouldn’t be interpreted as equivalent forecasts.

For consumers, the practical question is straightforward:

How much will your actual prescription drug plan cost next year—and is there a less expensive option that covers your medications?

Let’s examine the numbers, compare real products, and explain what to check before the December 7 enrollment deadline.

1. Why Medicare Part D Premiums Could Increase 50%

KFF’s October 30 analysis examines Medicare Part D plan premiums using data published by CMS.

Its central finding is that existing enrollees could experience a substantial increase in average monthly premiums if they remain in their current standalone prescription drug plans.

The Estimated Increase

Measure20262027
Average monthly premium under KFF’s same-plan analysis$34$51
Annual premium$408$612
Annual increase—$204
Percentage increase—50%

Source: KFF analysis of CMS Medicare Part D plan data. Figures are rounded, enrollment-weighted estimates assuming existing enrollees remain in their current plans.

The increase is substantial.

But the underlying assumption matters.

KFF’s projection examines the premiums current enrollees would face if they don’t move to less expensive alternatives.

It isn’t a forecast that every individual plan will increase its premium by 50%.

Some enrollees could face much larger increases.

Others could see only small changes.

And some may find lower-cost coverage by switching.

That’s why comparing plans during Open Enrollment could be especially important this year.

2. Why Does CMS Project Only $36?

At first glance, KFF’s $51 estimate seems inconsistent with CMS’s national projection.

CMS expects the average monthly premium for standalone Medicare prescription drug plans to increase from $35.09 in 2026 to approximately $36 in 2027.

That’s an increase of less than $1.

So which number is correct?

The distinction comes down to methodology.

KFF’s $51 figure estimates the cost of maintaining existing coverage, based on current enrollment patterns and 2027 plan premiums.

CMS’s $36 figure represents its separate national projection.

KFF notes that CMS has not fully explained the calculation methodology used for its estimate.

KFF has suggested that anticipated switching into lower-premium plans could help explain the difference, but that is a possible explanation rather than a confirmed description of CMS’s calculation.

Both findings highlight a critical point.

The cost of available coverage can be different from the cost of keeping the plan you already have.

For consumers, neither national estimate replaces an individualized plan comparison.

3. Real-World Comparison: Wellcare, Humana and AARP

To understand why Part D premiums vary so much, consider actual insurance products available for 2027.

KFF’s analysis identifies substantial differences among national standalone prescription drug plans.

Actual 2027 Part D Products

PlanProviderAverage Monthly Premium
Wellcare Value ScriptWellcare/Centene$6.50
Wellcare ClassicWellcare/Centene$10.90
Humana Premier RxHumana$137.40
AARP Medicare Rx PreferredUnitedHealthcare$204.50

Source: KFF analysis of CMS 2027 Medicare plan files.

These figures are averages across the applicable plan regions.

They’re not guaranteed premiums for a particular ZIP code.

A plan’s actual monthly cost can differ by location.

And the least expensive plan by premium isn’t necessarily the cheapest option after prescription costs are included.

That’s particularly important for someone taking several medications.

The Difference Is Enormous

Consider Wellcare Value Script and AARP Medicare Rx Preferred.

Their average monthly premiums differ by approximately $198.

Over a full year, that represents nearly $2,400 in premium differences.

But the plans may also differ in deductibles, covered medications, cost-sharing, and pharmacy networks.

A higher-premium plan might provide more favorable coverage for particular medications.

Whether that additional coverage justifies the premium depends on the drugs a beneficiary actually takes.

The correct comparison isn’t simply which product has the lowest advertised premium.

It’s which plan offers the lowest suitable total cost.

4. Wellcare Value Script: A Low-Premium Option

Wellcare Value Script is one of the lowest-premium national standalone Part D products for 2027.

KFF estimates its average monthly premium at approximately $6.50.

Wellcare advertises $0 copayments for Tier 1 prescriptions when filled at preferred cost-sharing pharmacies, subject to the plan’s terms.

That feature may be attractive to people who primarily use lower-cost generic medications.

However, not every prescription is classified as Tier 1.

More expensive drugs may fall into higher formulary tiers with different cost-sharing requirements.

Some medications may also require prior authorization or other coverage conditions.

What to Check

Before selecting Wellcare Value Script, confirm that:

  • Your medications are on the 2027 formulary.
  • Your preferred pharmacy participates in the applicable network.
  • Your medications qualify for the expected pricing tier.
  • You understand which drugs are subject to the deductible.

A low monthly premium provides little benefit if an important medication is not covered or requires substantially higher spending.

5. Wellcare Classic: Another Low-Premium Alternative

Wellcare Classic is another standalone Medicare Part D plan offered by Wellcare.

KFF estimates its average 2027 monthly premium at $10.90.

That’s only about $4.40 per month more than Wellcare Value Script’s national average.

Over a year, the difference is approximately $53.

But their benefit designs aren’t identical.

Different drug lists, tier assignments, deductibles, and pharmacy pricing can change which plan produces lower total costs.

For someone taking multiple prescriptions, those differences could outweigh the premium gap.

This is why comparing two plans from the same company can be worthwhile.

Even when the provider is identical, the available products can serve different needs.

6. Humana: Compare the Specific Plan

Humana offers several Medicare prescription drug products for 2027.

These include Humana Value Rx and Humana Premier Rx.

Humana Value Rx emphasizes access to prescription coverage through its network of participating pharmacies, including certain Walmart, Costco, Publix, and other retail locations.

Humana Premier Rx has a different benefit structure and is positioned as a more comprehensive prescription drug option.

KFF estimates an average monthly premium of $137.40 for Humana Premier Rx in 2027.

That is substantially higher than the national averages for Wellcare’s low-premium products.

But comparing premiums alone doesn’t establish which plan is better for a particular beneficiary.

Drug coverage can differ.

And a person using expensive brand-name medications may have very different priorities from someone taking only a few low-cost generics.

Humana also operates different plans across geographic markets.

Always verify the exact Humana plan offered in your ZIP code before comparing it with another insurer’s product.

7. AARP Medicare Rx Preferred: A Larger Premium Increase

One particularly notable example is AARP Medicare Rx Preferred, a UnitedHealthcare prescription drug product.

According to KFF, its average monthly premium is increasing from approximately $126 in 2026 to $204.50 in 2027.

That’s an increase of $78.50 per month.

Over 12 months, the difference is approximately $942.

The Cost of Staying With the Same Plan

Item20262027
Average monthly premium$126.00$204.50
Annual premium$1,512$2,454
Annual increase—$942

Source: KFF’s national plan-level premium analysis.

For a retiree living on a fixed income, an additional $942 per year could be significant.

However, the actual premium increase depends on the beneficiary’s location and plan.

And switching to another product isn’t automatically the right decision.

A replacement plan must also cover the medications the person needs.

The lesson is that an established insurance brand or familiar plan name doesn’t guarantee stable premiums.

Reviewing coverage annually can reveal changes that might otherwise go unnoticed.

8. Compare Total Annual Costs, Not Just Premiums

A low premium doesn’t necessarily mean a low total cost.

Consider two hypothetical Medicare Part D plans.

Example: Two Different Drug Plans

FeaturePlan APlan B
Monthly premium$6$50
Annual premiums$72$600
Estimated annual prescription cost-sharing$900$200
Estimated combined annual cost$972$800

In this example, Plan B has a much higher monthly premium.

But because it provides more favorable coverage for the beneficiary’s medications, its total estimated annual cost is lower.

The figures are hypothetical and do not represent actual quotes for a named insurance product.

They illustrate why shoppers should calculate the combined cost of premiums and expected prescription spending.

A consumer who looks only at the first row might choose Plan A.

A consumer who examines the full-year estimate might reach a different conclusion.

The best value depends on your actual prescriptions, pharmacy, and plan benefits.

9. What Is Changing With Part D Deductibles in 2027?

Premiums aren’t the only costs changing.

The maximum permitted annual Part D deductible is increasing to $700 in 2027.

That’s up from $615 in 2026.

Item20262027
Maximum Part D deductible$615$700
Annual Part D out-of-pocket threshold$2,100$2,400

Source: Medicare.gov.

Not every plan charges the maximum deductible.

Some offer lower deductibles or exempt certain drug tiers from deductible requirements.

The deductible is the amount you may need to pay for covered prescriptions before the applicable post-deductible cost-sharing provisions take effect.

For someone taking expensive medication, the deductible can influence costs early in the year.

That’s why reviewing deductible rules is especially important when comparing coverage.

10. The 2027 Prescription Drug Spending Limit

Medicare Part D includes an annual out-of-pocket threshold for covered prescription drugs.

For 2027, that threshold is $2,400.

Once an enrollee reaches the threshold under the program’s qualifying spending rules, they generally pay no additional cost-sharing for covered Part D drugs for the remainder of the calendar year.

This provides important protection against certain high prescription expenses.

But the threshold doesn’t include every healthcare cost.

Monthly insurance premiums don’t count toward the Part D out-of-pocket threshold.

Costs for medications that aren’t covered under Part D may also fall outside the protection.

Certain qualifying payments made on an enrollee’s behalf can count toward the threshold under Medicare’s rules.

Why Premiums Still Matter

Suppose someone pays $51 per month for Part D coverage and reaches the $2,400 out-of-pocket threshold.

Their combined annual premiums and qualifying prescription spending could total approximately:

$612 in premiums + $2,400 in drug spending = $3,012

This is an illustrative calculation, not an estimate that all beneficiaries will spend that amount.

It excludes unrelated medical expenses and any charges outside the applicable Part D protections.

The example shows why the annual spending limit doesn’t eliminate the importance of plan premiums.

11. Check Your Medications Before Changing Plans

For many beneficiaries, prescription coverage is the most important part of choosing a drug plan.

A plan’s formulary determines which medications it covers.

Plans also assign medications to different cost-sharing tiers.

A medication classified as preferred under one plan may receive less favorable treatment under another.

Example: A Person Taking Three Prescriptions

Imagine someone takes:

  • A generic cholesterol medication.
  • A brand-name diabetes medication.
  • A specialty medication for a chronic condition.

The generic prescription might have a very low copayment under multiple plans.

But the brand-name and specialty medications could carry much higher costs.

One insurer may place a medication on a preferred tier.

Another may require prior authorization or have different coverage conditions.

Those differences can produce substantial changes in annual spending.

Before switching, enter every regular prescription into Medicare’s official Plan Finder.

Use the exact drug name, dosage, quantity, and frequency.

Then compare estimated annual costs using your preferred pharmacies.

This is more reliable than assuming two plans with similar premiums provide equivalent coverage.

12. Your Pharmacy Can Change the Price

Pharmacy networks also matter.

Some Medicare drug plans have preferred pharmacies where certain prescriptions cost less.

Other in-network pharmacies may charge higher copayments or coinsurance.

For example, a plan might offer favorable pricing at a preferred retail chain or through a designated mail-order service.

But those arrangements can vary by location.

A pharmacy that’s preferred under one plan may not have the same status under another.

Before enrolling, check the cost of your medications at the pharmacies you actually use.

If you’re willing to change pharmacies, compare those options as well.

The lowest-cost plan at one pharmacy may not be the lowest-cost plan at another.

13. What If You Have Medicare Advantage?

The KFF analysis focuses on standalone Part D plans.

These are often used by people who receive their medical benefits through Original Medicare and obtain prescription coverage separately.

Medicare Advantage plans frequently include Part D drug coverage within the broader health insurance product.

These are commonly called Medicare Advantage Prescription Drug plans, or MA-PDs.

KFF estimates that the average Part D premium component of MA-PD coverage will be approximately $9 per month in 2027.

But that doesn’t mean a Medicare Advantage plan costs only $9 overall.

Most beneficiaries must continue paying their Medicare Part B premium, and medical cost-sharing, provider networks, and other coverage rules differ.

Switching from standalone drug coverage with Original Medicare to Medicare Advantage is a broader healthcare decision.

It shouldn’t be treated as a simple prescription premium comparison.

Similarly, enrolling in a standalone Part D plan while participating in certain Medicare Advantage plans can affect existing coverage.

Verify the applicable enrollment rules before changing products.

14. Two Programs That Could Help With Drug Costs

Medicare beneficiaries facing high prescription expenses may have additional options.

Extra Help

Medicare’s Extra Help program assists qualifying people with limited income and resources.

Depending on eligibility, it can reduce Part D premiums, deductibles, and prescription cost-sharing.

Consumers can review eligibility requirements through Medicare.gov or the Social Security Administration.

Medicare Prescription Payment Plan

The Medicare Prescription Payment Plan allows participating beneficiaries to spread covered out-of-pocket drug expenses across monthly payments.

This can make budgeting easier for someone facing substantial prescription costs early in the year.

However, the program doesn’t reduce the total amount owed.

It changes when qualifying expenses are paid, not the underlying drug cost.

That distinction is important when evaluating affordability.

15. How to Compare Your 2027 Plans

Medicare’s official Plan Finder allows consumers to compare prescription drug plans available in their area.

Here’s how to make the comparison useful.

Step 1: Enter Your ZIP Code

Drug plan availability and premiums vary by geographic area.

Your ZIP code helps identify applicable options.

Step 2: Select Prescription Drug Coverage

Choose standalone Part D plans if you’re comparing separate prescription drug coverage.

If you’re evaluating Medicare Advantage, compare the relevant health and drug coverage options together.

Step 3: Add Your Medications

Include the medications you regularly take.

Enter their dosage and frequency accurately.

Step 4: Select Your Pharmacies

Choose your preferred retail and mail-order pharmacies.

Plan estimates can change depending on the pharmacy.

Step 5: Compare Annual Costs

Look beyond the monthly premium.

Review estimated annual premiums, deductibles, prescription cost-sharing, and total costs.

Step 6: Check Coverage Restrictions

Review formulary status, prior authorization, quantity limits, and step therapy requirements.

Step 7: Confirm the Enrollment Deadline

For 2027 coverage, Medicare’s annual Open Enrollment Period ends December 7, 2026.

Changes made during the period generally take effect January 1, 2027.

16. Don’t Ignore Your Annual Notice of Change

Current Medicare plan members should receive an Annual Notice of Change.

This document explains important updates to the plan for the coming year.

It may describe changes to premiums, deductibles, copayments, covered drugs, and other benefits.

Even if you’re generally satisfied with your current coverage, reviewing the notice can help identify unexpected changes.

A plan that worked well in 2026 may not offer the same value in 2027.

And an insurer’s decision to continue offering a product doesn’t necessarily mean its coverage terms remain identical.

The PebbleWire Takeaway

Medicare Part D premiums could rise substantially in 2027 for people who stay in their current plans without comparing alternatives.

KFF estimates that average monthly premiums for existing standalone Part D enrollees could increase from $34 to $51 under a same-plan scenario.

But that increase isn’t universal.

Real-world products show substantial variation.

Wellcare Value Script has an estimated national average premium of $6.50, while AARP Medicare Rx Preferred averages $204.50.

Those differences highlight the importance of reviewing actual insurance options.

However, premiums are only part of the calculation.

A low-cost plan must still cover the medications you need at a reasonable total cost.

Before December 7, compare your prescription coverage, pharmacy network, deductible, and estimated annual spending.

And don’t assume that automatically renewing your existing plan is the best choice.

A few minutes comparing coverage today could prevent months of unnecessary insurance expenses in 2027.


Sources

  1. KFF — Medicare Part D Premiums and Cost Sharing in 2027, October 30, 2026.
  2. KFF — The Average Monthly Premium for Medicare Part D Stand-Alone Plans Is Projected to Increase by 50%, October 30, 2026.
  3. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services — Medicare Advantage and Medicare Prescription Drug Programs Expected to Remain Stable in 2027.
  4. Medicare.gov — How Much Does Medicare Drug Coverage Cost?
  5. Medicare.gov — Medicare Open Enrollment.
  6. Medicare.gov — Medicare Plan Finder.
  7. Wellcare — Wellcare Value Script 2027.
  8. Wellcare — Wellcare Classic 2027.
  9. Humana — 2027 Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plans.
  10. Medicare.gov — Extra Help With Drug Costs.
  11. Medicare.gov — Medicare Prescription Payment Plan.

Source verification date: November 5, 2026.

Editorial verification notes: KFF’s $51 projection applies to existing standalone Part D enrollees under a same-plan scenario. CMS’s $36 national projection uses a separately reported estimate whose methodology has not been fully explained. Product premiums are national plan averages rather than individualized quotes. Annual cost illustrations are hypothetical unless explicitly attributed to KFF or CMS.

Disclaimer

PebbleWire provides financial news and educational content for informational purposes only. This article does not constitute personalized financial, medical, insurance, tax, or legal advice. Medicare plan availability, premiums, drug coverage, and enrollment rules may vary. Review official plan materials and consult Medicare.gov, the relevant insurer, or a qualified State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor before making coverage decisions.

MORE TO EXPLORE

PEBBLEWIRE / FINANCIAL CLARITY FOR EVERY DAY