PEBBLEWIRE /

High-Yield Savings vs. Treasury Bills After the Fed’s Rate Hold

Treasury bills are yielding more than some popular high-yield savings accounts. We compare Ally, Marcus, and U.S. Treasury bills to show what $10,000 could earn, including taxes and liquidity trade-offs.

Keeping cash in a savings account is supposed to be simple.

You deposit money, earn interest, and withdraw it when you need it.

But with short-term U.S. Treasury bills offering annualized yields above 4%, some savers have another option worth considering.

The Federal Reserve held its benchmark interest rate at 3.75%–4.00% during its October 28 meeting.

That decision leaves consumers comparing a range of short-term cash products with different yields, tax treatments, and withdrawal rules.

Consider three real-world options: Ally Bank, Marcus by Goldman Sachs, and U.S. Treasury bills.

As of November 3, a 13-week Treasury bill carried a secondary-market annualized yield of 4.13%.

Marcus advertised 3.50% APY, while independent rate monitoring placed Ally’s Online Savings Account at approximately 3.20% APY.

At first glance, Treasury bills appear to win.

But the highest yield isn’t necessarily the best choice for money you might need tomorrow.

Here’s how the options compare.

Ally vs. Marcus vs. Treasury Bills: The Numbers

Let’s start with the available rates.

ProductReported YieldRate Type
Ally Online Savings3.20% APYVariable
Marcus Online Savings3.50% APYVariable
13-week Treasury bill4.13%Annualized market yield
26-week Treasury bill4.30%Annualized market yield

Rate reference: November 3, 2026.

Sources: Ally and Marcus product information, independent Ally rate monitoring, and U.S. Treasury daily secondary-market bill rates.

Ally’s 3.20% figure requires confirmation against the bank’s latest rate disclosure before publication.

These numbers show a clear difference in the rates available during the comparison period.

The 13-week Treasury bill offered a yield approximately 0.63 percentage points higher than Marcus and 0.93 percentage points higher than Ally.

But there are important distinctions.

Savings account APYs include the effects of compounding over a year, assuming the rate remains unchanged.

Treasury bill yields are quoted on an annualized basis using conventions that differ from savings account APYs.

They’re useful for comparison, but the two figures aren’t mathematically identical.

More importantly, savings rates can change after you deposit money.

A Treasury bill purchased at a particular price provides a defined return at maturity, assuming the U.S. government fulfills its obligations.

1. Ally Bank: A Flexible Option for Everyday Savings

Ally Bank is an online bank offering savings accounts, checking accounts, certificates of deposit, and other financial products.

Its Online Savings Account is designed for consumers who want to earn interest while retaining access to their money.

Ally Online Savings Account

FeatureAlly Online Savings
Reported APY3.20%
Monthly maintenance fee$0
Minimum opening deposit$0
Interest rateVariable
FDIC insuranceYes, subject to applicable limits
AccessOnline and mobile transfers
Savings toolsSavings buckets and boosters

Ally’s savings buckets allow customers to organize money for different goals within the same account.

For example, you could designate portions of your savings for an emergency fund, vacation, home repairs, or an upcoming tax bill.

You don’t need to open a separate savings account for every goal.

That’s useful for someone who wants to keep savings organized without managing multiple banking relationships.

What to Watch

Ally limits certain withdrawals and transfers from its savings accounts to 10 per statement cycle.

The bank says it doesn’t charge a fee for exceeding that limit, although repeated violations can result in account closure.

Its APY is also variable.

If Ally changes its deposit rates, your future earnings can change.

Best fit: Savers who value convenient access, budgeting tools, and straightforward account management.

2. Marcus: A Simple High-Yield Savings Account

Marcus by Goldman Sachs offers a different approach.

Its Online Savings Account emphasizes a competitive interest rate without requiring customers to maintain a minimum balance.

Marcus Online Savings Account

FeatureMarcus Online Savings
Advertised APY3.50%
Monthly maintenance fee$0
Minimum opening deposit$0
Interest rateVariable
FDIC insuranceYes, subject to applicable limits
AccessTransfers to linked bank accounts
Interest compoundingDaily

Marcus is a brand of Goldman Sachs Bank USA.

Its savings account is designed primarily for earning interest on cash rather than everyday spending.

Customers can link external bank accounts and move money electronically.

Marcus also advertises same-day transfer capabilities for qualifying transactions, subject to its transfer terms and processing requirements.

What Makes Marcus Different?

Compared with Ally, Marcus focuses more directly on the savings experience.

It doesn’t offer Ally’s particular savings-bucket features.

Instead, its appeal centers on earning interest with relatively simple account requirements.

At the reported rates, Marcus offers a higher APY than Ally.

But the difference may be smaller in dollar terms than it initially appears.

And because both rates are variable, today’s advantage may not persist.

Best fit: Savers seeking a straightforward interest-bearing account who don’t need Ally’s budgeting features.

3. Treasury Bills: Higher Yields With a Maturity Date

Treasury bills, commonly called T-bills, are short-term debt securities issued by the U.S. government.

When you purchase one, you’re lending money to the federal government for a specified period.

Treasury bills generally are sold at a discount to their face value.

When the bill matures, the Treasury pays its face value.

The difference between the purchase price and the amount received at maturity represents your earnings.

For example, suppose you purchase a Treasury bill with a $10,000 face value for $9,900.

At maturity, you receive $10,000.

Your earnings would be $100.

The exact purchase price depends on market conditions and auction results.

Current Treasury Bill Yields

The U.S. Treasury reported the following coupon-equivalent secondary-market yields for November 3, 2026:

MaturityAnnualized Yield
4 weeks3.95%
8 weeks4.07%
13 weeks4.13%
26 weeks4.30%
52 weeks4.40%

These are market quotations, not guaranteed yields for future auctions.

The actual return on a newly purchased Treasury bill depends on its purchase price and maturity.

Unlike a savings account, however, the return on a Treasury bill held to maturity is determined by the price paid and the amount due at maturity.

That can make Treasury bills useful when you know exactly when you’ll need your money.

4. What Would $10,000 Actually Earn?

Let’s compare the three options over approximately three months.

Assume you have $10,000 available and won’t need to use it for 91 days.

We’ll compare Ally’s reported 3.20% APY, Marcus’s 3.50% APY, and the November 3 secondary-market yield of 4.13% on a 13-week Treasury bill.

Three-Month Interest Comparison

ProductStarting CashEstimated Interest
Ally Online Savings$10,000$78.84
Marcus Online Savings$10,000$86.14
13-week Treasury bill$10,000$102.97

Calculation assumptions: Savings rates remain unchanged for 91 days, interest is compounded consistently with the stated APY, and no withdrawals or fees occur. Treasury bill interest is approximated using the quoted annualized yield over 91 days. Figures are before taxes.

The Treasury bill produces the highest estimated return.

Compared with Ally, the difference is approximately $24 over the period.

Compared with Marcus, it’s approximately $17.

Those differences matter, but they also put the rate comparison into perspective.

For a $10,000 balance, the additional return over three months isn’t enormous.

If you need frequent access to your money, the convenience of a savings account may be worth more than the difference in earnings.

For a much larger balance, the difference could become more significant.

5. Treasury Bills Have a Tax Advantage

One of the most important differences between savings accounts and Treasury bills is how their earnings are taxed.

Interest from an ordinary bank savings account is generally subject to federal income tax and, where applicable, state and local income taxes.

Treasury bill interest is also subject to federal income tax.

But it is exempt from state and local income taxes.

That distinction can improve the after-tax return for investors living in states that tax interest income.

Real-World Tax Comparison

Let’s return to the $10,000 example.

Assume the investor faces:

  • A 22% federal marginal income tax rate.
  • A 5% state marginal income tax rate.
  • No additional local income tax.

For illustration, we’ll apply these rates directly to the estimated interest.

ProductPretax InterestEstimated After-Tax Interest
Ally Online Savings$78.84$57.55
Marcus Online Savings$86.14$62.88
13-week Treasury bill$102.97$80.31

The Treasury bill retains a larger portion of its return because its interest isn’t subject to state income tax.

In this example, it generates approximately $17 more after taxes than Marcus over the same period.

These calculations are simplified illustrations.

Actual tax liability can depend on filing status, state-specific rules, deductions, and other income.

Someone living in a state without a personal income tax won’t receive the same state-tax advantage.

But for residents of higher-tax states, the exemption can make Treasury bills particularly attractive.

6. What About Safety?

Both FDIC-insured savings accounts and U.S. Treasury bills are widely used for preserving cash.

But their protections work differently.

Savings Accounts

Ally Bank and Goldman Sachs Bank USA are FDIC-insured institutions.

Eligible deposits are generally insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, for each ownership category.

That means your savings are protected within the applicable limits if an insured bank fails.

However, multiple accounts at the same bank don’t automatically increase your coverage.

Treasury Bills

Treasury bills are direct obligations of the U.S. government.

They are backed by the full faith and credit of the United States.

They aren’t FDIC-insured bank deposits.

When held to maturity, their repayment depends on the government’s ability and willingness to meet its obligations.

If you sell before maturity, however, market prices can change.

That introduces the possibility of receiving less than expected.

The key distinction: Savings accounts provide deposit insurance and relatively convenient access. Treasury bills provide a government payment obligation at maturity but can fluctuate in market value before that date.

7. Which One Gives You Faster Access to Cash?

Liquidity may be the deciding factor.

A savings account is generally designed to let you transfer or withdraw funds when needed.

Treasury bills work differently.

They have specific maturity dates.

If you hold a bill until maturity, your proceeds are paid according to the security’s terms.

If you need the money earlier, you may have to sell the bill in the secondary market.

And that isn’t always immediate or convenient.

TreasuryDirect Has an Important Restriction

Investors can purchase Treasury bills through TreasuryDirect, the government’s official investment platform.

But newly issued Treasury marketable securities purchased through TreasuryDirect generally must be held for at least 45 calendar days before they can be transferred.

TreasuryDirect doesn’t offer a direct secondary-market selling function.

To sell an eligible bill before maturity, you generally must transfer it to a bank, broker, or dealer.

A four-week Treasury bill purchased at original issue through TreasuryDirect cannot be transferred for an early sale because it matures before the 45-day holding period ends.

That limitation matters if the money is intended for emergencies.

Treasury bills purchased and held through a brokerage account may provide greater selling flexibility, although market-price risk still applies.

8. When a High-Yield Savings Account Makes More Sense

A high-yield savings account may be preferable when liquidity and convenience are more important than maximizing yield.

Consider money intended for:

  • Emergency expenses.
  • Upcoming bills with uncertain payment dates.
  • Short-term household spending.
  • Expenses that may require immediate access.

Suppose you keep $10,000 as an emergency fund.

At the rates examined, moving it from Marcus into a 13-week Treasury bill might generate approximately $17 more before taxes over 91 days.

That additional return may not justify reduced access to the money.

A savings account can also be simpler for someone who doesn’t want to manage Treasury auctions or maturity dates.

9. When Treasury Bills Make More Sense

Treasury bills may be attractive when you can leave the money invested for a known period.

For example, suppose you’re saving for a large expense due in six months.

You have enough accessible emergency savings elsewhere and don’t expect to use this particular cash before the payment date.

A 26-week Treasury bill could provide a relatively predictable maturity value.

At the November 3 market quotation, the annualized yield was 4.30%.

That was higher than the rates examined for both Ally and Marcus.

For someone in a state with income taxes, Treasury bills may also offer a useful after-tax advantage.

However, a new bill purchased at a future auction may have a different yield.

And investors should avoid choosing a maturity date that falls after the money is needed.

10. What About Splitting Your Money?

You don’t necessarily have to choose only one account or investment.

A combination can provide both liquidity and yield.

Consider a hypothetical $20,000 cash reserve.

AllocationAmountPurpose
High-yield savings account$10,000Immediate financial needs
13-week Treasury bills$5,000Short-term savings
26-week Treasury bills$5,000Cash not needed for six months
Total$20,000

This structure keeps part of the money accessible while investing the remainder across different maturity dates.

As each bill matures, you can decide whether to spend the proceeds, move them into savings, or reinvest.

This is a simplified example of a Treasury bill ladder.

The approach won’t be appropriate for everyone.

Households with limited emergency savings may prefer to maintain greater liquidity.

But for people with substantial cash reserves, separating immediate needs from predictable future expenses can be useful.

Head to Head: Which Is Better?

Your PriorityOption Worth Considering
Immediate access to cashHigh-yield savings
Straightforward online savingsMarcus
Savings buckets and budgeting toolsAlly
Higher yield for a known holding periodTreasury bills
State income-tax advantagesTreasury bills
FDIC-insured depositsAlly or Marcus
Defined maturity valueTreasury bills
Emergency fundHigh-yield savings

These are practical distinctions, not universal product rankings.

Account availability, tax circumstances, interest rates, and cash needs can change which choice is most appropriate.

The PebbleWire Takeaway

Treasury bills currently offer higher quoted yields than Ally and Marcus savings accounts, but earning more interest isn’t the only consideration.

At the latest available rates, a $10,000 investment over approximately three months could generate about $103 in Treasury bill interest, compared with $86 at Marcus and $79 at Ally.

Treasury bills may also benefit from their exemption from state and local income taxes.

But savings accounts offer greater flexibility.

You generally don’t need to worry about maturity dates or selling securities to access your money.

For emergency funds, that convenience can be extremely valuable.

For cash with a predictable spending date, Treasury bills may deserve a closer look.

The most effective approach may be to use both.

Keep accessible money where you can reach it. Put money you won’t need immediately where the combination of yield, taxes, and risk makes the most sense.


Sources

  1. Federal Reserve Board — Federal Open Market Committee Statement, October 28, 2026.
  2. Ally Bank — Online Savings Account and Deposit Account Rates.
  3. Marcus by Goldman Sachs — High-Yield Online Savings Account.
  4. U.S. Department of the Treasury — Daily Treasury Bill Rates, November 3, 2026.
  5. TreasuryDirect — Treasury Bills.
  6. TreasuryDirect — Selling a Treasury Marketable Security.
  7. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation — Deposit Insurance at a Glance.
  8. Internal Revenue Service — Topic No. 403: Interest Received.

Rate reference date: November 3, 2026.

Calculation methodology: Savings interest is estimated using APY-based compound growth over 91 days. Treasury bill interest is estimated using a 91-day holding period and the November 3 annualized coupon-equivalent secondary-market yield. Calculations exclude fees, transaction spreads, and rate changes. After-tax comparisons apply illustrative federal and state marginal tax rates directly to estimated interest.

Editorial verification note: Marcus’s 3.50% APY and Treasury bill market yields are supported by primary-source disclosures. Ally’s 3.20% APY is supported by November 3 independent rate observations but requires direct issuer confirmation before publication. Rates and product conditions may change.

Disclaimer

PebbleWire provides financial news and educational content for informational purposes only. This article does not constitute personalized financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. Interest rates, product terms, and yields may change. Treasury securities can experience market-price fluctuations if sold before maturity. Actual returns and taxes depend on individual circumstances. Ally, Marcus, and Treasury bills are discussed for educational comparison and are not individualized recommendations.

MORE TO EXPLORE

PEBBLEWIRE / FINANCIAL CLARITY FOR EVERY DAY